The Supreme Court upheld Texas’s ability to enforce a law that allows the state’s law enforcement to detain immigrants, dishing out a devastating blow to the Biden administration’s more lenient immigration stance.The conservative dismissed the federal government’s argument that immigration policy is solely under federal jurisdiction.

Texas Law

This set the stage for the Texas law to be implemented while further litigation proceeds in lower courts. 

Source: Flickr/Gage Skidmore

Despite this the future of the law remains uncertain, and it could very easily be overturned. 

Balance Of Authority 

Justice Sonia Sotomayor opposed this view saying it disrupts the balance between federal and state power.  

Source: Flickr/Gage Skidemore

Justice Sotomayor said, “The court gives a green light to a law that will upend the longstanding federal-state balance of power and sow chaos.” 

Migrants Seeking Entry

The increasing number of individuals at the border that are seeking entry into the United States is a contentious issue, igniting serious divisions and a variety of perspectives among Americans. 

Source: Unsplash/Metin Ozer

Insight from a Pew Research Center survey that was conducted on January 16-21, 2024, among 5,140 adults, the public’s perspective and concerns regarding the situation at the United States and Mexican border offer important insight into the complex nature of this ongoing crisis.  

Justice Amy Coney 

Justice Amy Coney Barrett said,

Source: Morry Gash

“If a decision does not issue soon, the applicants may return to this court.” 

Authority To Enforce Laws 

Texas made the argument that it has the authority to enforce laws that complement the federal policies to address the security concerns for the border.

Source: Kim Kyung-Hoon

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton said the Constitution “recognizes that Texas has the sovereign right to defend itself from violent transnational cartels that flood the state with fentanyl, weapons, and all manner of brutality.”

Possibly Deporting

The law in Texas allows law enforcement to detain and possibly deport individuals for state offenses related to illegal entry, escalating penalties for repeat offenses. 

Source: US Newspaper

It signifies significant expansion of state power that a previous federal judge had blocked, citing federal primacy over immigration law.

Americans Commonly Attribute 

The Pew Research Center finds that Americans largely attribute migrant increase to economic factors, such as poor conditions in migrants’ home countries and better economic opportunities in the United States. 

Source: Flickr/Gage Skidmore

About 71% of Americans view better economic opportunities in the United States as a major reason for the influx. Whereas 65% of Americans cite violence in migrants’ home countries as a driving factor, with notable partisan differences in perceptions of these factors.

Most Americans

A significant number of Americans see the mass quantities of migrants seeking entry at the United States- Mexico border as a serious problem or crisis. 

Source: Unsplash/Alejandro Cartagena

Clearly showing that Americans are looking for a solution from the government.  

Migrants Arriving At The Border 

The survey underscored the vast partisan disparities in attributing the migrant increase to specified factors. 

Source: BBC

Democrats are more likely to attribute the increase to violence in the migrants home country, while Republicans think that U.S. immigration policies contribute significantly to the surge of migrants coming to the border.

Notable Partisan Differences

With worth noting the significant differences in how Republicans and Democrats categorize the situation, 

Source: Unsplash/Kelly Sikkema

with 70% of Republicans describing it as a crisis, compared to only 22% of Democrats.

Financial Burdens

The financial challenges linked to the influx and security concerns, specifically concerns about crime,

Source: YouTube/Noticias Telemundo

Indicate the multifaceted nature of public apprehensions surrounding the crisis.

Government’s Strategy 

The large number of Americans that criticize the federal government’s handling of the situation at the U.S.-Mexico border, 

Source: Unsplash/Greg Bulla

with only 18% indicating trust in the government’s strategies to tackle this matter. 

Policy Action

The survey also discusses the potential for policy action that could improve the situation at the border. 

Source: Flickr/Gage Skidmore

While there is no single policy proposal that earns the majority support from both Republicans and Democrats, increasing the number of immigration judges and staff to expedite asylum decisions emerges as a potential area of relative agreement, with 60% of Americans perceiving it as a measure that could enhance the situation at the border.

Republicans And Democrats

Both Republicans and Democrats alike share the same unfavorable sentiments regarding the government’s management of the crisis, 

Source: Flickr/Gage Skidmore

With Democrats showing particularly heightened dissatisfaction, showing the highest levels ever recorded during President Biden’s tenure.